Artisan Milled vs. Hand Spun Alpaca Yarn: What’s the Difference?

If you’ve ever held two skeins of alpaca yarn in your hands—one smooth and evenly spun, the other full of texture and natural variation—and wondered why they feel so different, you’re not alone. As you grow more thoughtful about the materials you use, it’s normal to start asking deeper questions.

Many makers reach a point where they wonder: What is the difference between artisan milled and hand spun alpaca yarn? And which one should I choose for my projects?

At Enchanted Fibers, we work with alpaca fiber from the day it’s sheared through every step of processing—whether it’s sent to a small artisan mill or spun by hand in our studio. After working with hundreds of fleeces, we’ve seen how these choices shape the final yarn.

In this post, you’ll learn how artisan milled and hand spun alpaca yarn are made, how they differ in texture and performance, and how to choose the right yarn for your knitting, crochet, or fiber art projects.

Artisan milled alpaca yarn is spun in small batches at professional fiber mills using specialized equipment, creating consistent, even yarn.

Hand spun alpaca yarn is made one skein at a time by a spinner using a wheel or spindle, creating unique, textured yarn with natural variation.

The main difference is consistency versus individuality.

Every skein of alpaca yarn begins with careful shearing and fleece preparation.

After cleaning and sorting, fiber follows one of two paths:

• Sent to a small artisan mill for professional processing

• Prepared and spun by hand in our studio

Both methods respect the fiber and support sustainable, small-scale production.

Artisan milled alpaca yarn is processed in small batches at specialized fiber mills that focus on natural fibers.

How Artisan Milled Yarn Is Made

The fiber is:

• Washed and cleaned

• Carded into smooth rovings

• Spun by machine

• Wound into skeins

Skilled technicians monitor each step for quality.

Characteristics of Artisan Milled Yarn

Artisan milled yarn is typically:

• Even in thickness

• Smooth and soft

• Consistent between skeins

• Easy to substitute in patterns

Benefits of Artisan Milled Yarn

Makers choose artisan milled yarn because it:

• Works well with published patterns

• Makes gauge easier to match

• Produces polished garments

• Is beginner-friendly

Artisan milled yarn offers predictable thickness, twist, and stitch definition.

Hand spun yarn offers variation, texture, and creative freedom.

If you prefer reliability, choose milled yarn.

If you enjoy artistic expression, choose hand spun.

Choose Artisan Milled Yarn If You:

• Are making sweaters or fitted garments

• Follow patterns closely

• Want consistent results

• Are new to knitting or crochet

Choose Hand Spun Yarn If You:

• Enjoy adapting patterns

• Make shawls, scarves, or art pieces

• Love texture and variation

• Value handmade artistry

Many makers use both depending on the project.

Both artisan milled and hand spun alpaca yarn are durable when cared for properly.

How to Care for Alpaca Yarn

• Hand wash in cool water

• Use gentle soap

• Do not wring

• Lay flat to dry

• Store clean and dry

Proper care helps alpaca garments last for decades.

Alpaca fiber supports eco-friendly and slow fashion practices.

Sustainability of Artisan Milled Yarn

• Small-batch processing

• Low waste

• Efficient fiber use

Sustainability of Hand Spun Yarn

• Minimal energy use

• Low environmental impact

• Full use of small quantities

Both methods support responsible fiber stewardship.

Artisan Milled Yarn

• Produced in batches

• More widely available

• Lower price per skein

Hand Spun Yarn

• Made individually

• Very limited supply

• Higher price due to labor

Price reflects time, skill, and scale of production.

Each alpaca fleece is evaluated for:

• Softness

• Staple length

• Strength

• Color

• Quantity

This helps us decide whether fiber is best suited for milling, hand spinning, or both.

Projects Using Artisan Milled Yarn

• Sweaters

• Hats

• Blankets

• Everyday scarves

Projects Using Hand Spun Yarn

• Heirloom shawls

• Statement wraps

• Art knitting

• Special gifts

We offer both because:

• Makers have different needs

• Creativity changes with seasons

• Every fleece deserves its best use

• We value both precision and artistry

Our goal is to honor the fiber and support thoughtful making.

If you’re unsure, ask yourself:

• Do I want predictability or creativity?

• Am I following a pattern?

• Is this a gift or a personal project?

• Do I enjoy experimenting?

Your answers will guide your choice.

Is hand spun alpaca yarn better than milled yarn?

No. Hand spun yarn is more unique and artistic, while milled yarn is more consistent and predictable. Each serves different purposes.

Is artisan milled yarn still handmade?

Yes. While machines spin the yarn, skilled artisans oversee every step in small-batch production.

Can beginners use hand spun yarn?

Yes, but beginners often find artisan milled yarn easier to work with at first.

How long does alpaca yarn last?

With proper care, alpaca yarn garments can last many years or even decades.

Every skein of alpaca yarn tells a story.

Some are shaped by small mills and careful systems.

Some are shaped by hands and quiet hours at the wheel.

Both begin on our farm.

Both are made with care.

Both are meant to be enjoyed.

When you choose artisan milled or hand spun alpaca yarn, you’re choosing how you want to connect with your materials—and with the people and animals behind them.

Check out the yarn offerings at Enchanted Fibers Yarns.

Stay Close to the Heart of Enchanted Fibers

From the alpacas who grow the fiber to the hands that shape each piece, everything we create carries a story.

Join The Enchanted Circle for gentle updates, behind-the-scenes moments from the ranch, and first looks at new wearables and yarns.

A warm, creativity-filled community—no noise, just meaning.